Al Gore’s RealSimple “We” Campaign
Posted by Allison Fine on March 31, 2008
Al Gore just announced a new campaign to $300 million climate change campaign. It’s a very slick website called We Can Solve the Climate Crisis, or We for Short.
At the risk of being totally un-PC for We, I have some problems here (and I’m not talking about the shock of seeing the phrase, “Nobel laureate former Vice President Al Gore” — didn’t I just know him as boring Al?) So, here are difficulties that I have with this:
1. I wonder how much of that $300 million has gone into this too-slick web site. I’ve been wondering for a while where the first social media-driven global advocacy campaign was going to come from, and I imagined that it would come from young people using their social networks and Twittering and poking one another around the globe to press for drastic climate change. I was hoping that it wouldn’t look like an online version of RealSimple magazine.
2. This is probably an extension of the point above, but in addition to the slick feel of the sight are the creepy “real” people talking to me. I think I’d feel better if they were just actors rather than real people who are called “presenters”. I have no idea what that means. I really wish this site felt more like craigslist and less like Disney world.
3. In a truly disempowering sense, the We campaign already has it all figured out — and all we, the robotic consumer people who don’t look as attractive as the “presenters” have to do is click here, buy this, give them our name and email address and the names and email addresses of our nearest and dearest and the problem will be solved! Hey, ad exec. people making millions of dollars, we regular people may have some ideas of what to do, who to talk to, how to organize ourselves that hasn’t been focused grouped and put into pale colors yet!
I’ve got to get off this site, it’s making me really cranky!
6 Responses to “Al Gore’s RealSimple “We” Campaign”
Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.


gbrandonthomas said
Great thoughts, Allison! Rather than pile on to what is missing, I went ahead and broke out a few of the key (and easy) opportunities they have to engage in what is becoming the social web…
More of my musings…
Allison Fine said
Thanks, there is great info on your site!
bensheldon said
That is so awe-disinspiring! It’s the same way I feel about the guys/gals in matching jackets and clip-boards who have shiny brochures for social cause X, standing on the street corner asking for money and money only—they’re called Charity Muggers. It’s a professionalization of social activism that converts honest concern and action into some rote consumptive step.
Check out the book “Dream: Re-imagining Progressive Politics in an Age of Fantasy” by Stephen Duncombe; it talks a lot about this sort of thing.
Allison Fine said
Thanks, Ben. Awe-disinspiring is a great way to put it! Why do smart people like Al Gore fall for ad agency suits selling them top-down astroturf like this?? It’s so disappointing given how ready people are to participating in real, meaningful ways in a global climate change movement. A real movement is coming, just not by this group!
Allison
We Can Solve It? — Invested Citizens. 投資公民. 시민 투자한. استثمر المواطنين said
[...] In trying to learn more about it, I came across a few links which I think are worth looking at. Alex Steffen at WorldChanging.org has a good summary of the opinions out there. Allison Fine, the author of Momentum: Igniting Social Change in the Connected Age and a senior fellow at Demos, had this to say at her “A. Fine Blog.” [...]
dreamtofly said
Hey Allison, I came across your work researching the ‘we’ campaign and i thought i’d put in a plug for my own project: Invested Citizens. We’re an international community working to collectively address issues like climate change with grassroots, democratic venture capital. We’re just getting started, but hopefully we can fill that gap for you and give you some hope. Thanks for the work you do.